No, such real-files testing are important to get the details ironed out. The more the better
The surprise is, it seems to have managed to render as a hole.
Has anyone tried to import footprints with slots from Eagle ? (plated and non plated ?)
Testing this some more, I find it almost works 100%, and is probably good enough to import.
- Greyed out menu means you cannot create Edge.Cuts inside a footprint. (imposed rule)
*** However, looks like you can Edit or import Edge.Cuts entity just fine inside footprint.**
*** Such contained Edge.Cut does Gerber plot, and it is seen by Fill as a keepout.**
- Missing is visibility to routing. ie shove does NOT avoid footprint Edge.Cut
- Also missing is DRC checks on traces across Edge Cuts, but that's not related to Eagle Import.
From that, I'd say the Eagle import is working fine.
The 'bodge' bobc mentions, imports as the same bodge, and does make it to the gerbers, so I'd expect the gerbers KiCad <-> Eagle are close to matching.
KiCad does not yet have full routing visibility on the footprint keepout, so that's a caveat, but I believe support of footprint cutout is on the road map (or certainly should be), so I'd say the translation is correct here.
KiCad ideally should also have DRC checking for traces across Edge.cuts