Found another incorrectly drawn component in the default libraries

Not sure whatever became of my raising an issue of a MC6821 masquerading as a MC6840 in the libraries, but I found another badly drawn / defined symbol.

This one is the 4078 in the 4xxx-IEEE library.

Missing the alternate output (pin 1), half the input pins are flagged as outputs???, and one even as a power input?!

I already rolled my own and moved on (other than the Device library, most of the schematics I have now use symbols from my personal ‘master library’ instead. Easier that way).

v7.0.10 Mac version

I would say that the kicad library is a gift to the community. It lets users quickly get started building up a personal library – copy the parts you need, organize as you see fit, and tweak whatever is needed to suit your needs. This comprehensive work has an incredible amount of valuable content.

Also, it seems many users don’t build personal libraries and are well-served by the kicad collection.

Yeah, there will be some glitches here and there, but I imagine repairs are not a particularly high priority for the limited hours devs have. Speaking of which, a great big thank you to the kicad library maintainers is in order!

I remember eagerly reading through mc6800 docs around the same time I learned z80 assembly. And I have designed quite a few things with good-ol metal-gate 4000 cmos. But that was decades ago – what sort of retro gizmo are you designing @Meterman2026 ?

1 Like

Did you raise a Bug report on GitLab ?

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.

In re:

I believe I did raise an issue, but it was dismissed as low-priority (probably no time for ‘old’ parts given the dizzying number of atomic-level parts currently in the library).

As for what the project was I needed the 4078 for, I was documenting a circuit board as part of a small data preservation project - see the clip:

As mentioned above:

It’s unclear if by raising you meant posting on this forum.

I believe I made my way over to Gitlab and raised an issue over there. I seem to remember that it was closed without comment a short while later, so I didn’t bother following up any further.

Can you share the link to the issue? It could be it was closed by the Gitlab robot because something was missing from the report.

First, were there a couple different sites?

I just checked at this site: KiCad Libraries · GitLab and I am not finding anything in search over there.

The KiCad repos moved from GitHub to GitLab some years ago, maybe you were at the GitHub site?

Possible. I just tried to search over there and got a “secondary rate limit exceeded” error…

At GitLab after signing in I can in search box select Author then is (=) and then select myself and after clicking magnifying glass icon I have only my issues.

Any of these yours?

Nope, on GitLab . . . just as if you had gone to KiCad Help > Report Bug

image

I believe this was fixed here. Is there still an outstanding issue?

1 Like

The issue I raised was on the 6840. Interface / MC6840 is somehow a clone of the 6821… the former is a 28-pin package but the 6821 is 40 pins.

I didn’t bother going any further as I’ve been rolling my own parts rather than relying on KiCAD’s libraries.

That was fixed 10 months ago in Reinstate MC6840 from old library (and add some rework) (!4226) · Merge requests · KiCad / KiCad Libraries / KiCad Symbols · GitLab

2 Likes

Issue here was closed as duplicate because it was reported multiple times Incorrect symbol for MC6840 Programmable Timer Module (#3243) · Issues · KiCad / KiCad Libraries / KiCad Symbols · GitLab

2 Likes