My 2cents. Stop wasting your time comparing and just use KiCAD. The program you know how to use the best will be the best. Design a few boards and have them made. Note that any errors are yours and KiCad warned you. With KiCad there are no down sides, no company mergers, divestitures, new CEO wants to make things more efficient, a subscription plan is what our users want or uninformed investors decided some crap BS.
The only problem with KiCad is that it is so good and so cool that it’s no longer free for me. I feel I have to donate an amount commensurate with my enjoyment and productivity each year.